Bibliography

1] Francis Marion Haughey letters.  Part of the “Crandall papers” at the Missouri Historical Society. St Louis, Mo. Copyright MHS

2] Francis Marion Haughey letter,  Dated Feb 6, 1910 to wife and children.  For my photocopy of this letter I am indebted to Frank Hess.

3] Crandall, Warren D, and Isaac D. Newell. History of the Ram Fleet and Marine Brigade, Buschart Brothers,  St Louis, 1907

4] Hearn, Chester G., Ellet’s Brigade The Strangest Outfit of All  Baton Rouge,  2000

5] National Archives & Records Administration (www.nara.gov) Military Service files for Francis Marion Haughey in the 44th Indiana Infantry, company F.

6] Dr. Robert E. King and Doris R Jones. History of the King Family in Flanders & America.   Photo copy printed in 1980 in Pullman Washington

7] US Census record, Harrison Township, Iowa 1870, F.M. Haughey family

8] US Census record, Kokomo, Summit County, Colorado, 1880 Francis Marion Haughey

9] US Census record, Eureka, Humbolt county, California for 1910, 1920, and 1930.  Robert Haughey family.

10] Moffat County, Colorado obituary for Francis Marion Haughey February 1910.  Transcription courtesy of Phyllis Bingham   http://www.rootsweb.com/~comoffat/ObitDetail1900-1910.htm

11] Empire-Courier, Newspaper, Craig Colorado. May 13, 1965   Obituary for
Mrs. Blanch Maud Hess  (F.M. Haughey’s daughter). Courtesy of Frank Hess

12] Newspaper Obituary for Francis Marion  “In Memoriam-Serg. Francis M. Haughey” Date and newspaper unknown. Courtesy of Frank Hess

13] Newspaper Clipping entitled “Colorado Pioneers at Craig” Date and newspaper unknown.  Approximately 1952.  Courtesy of Frank Hess

14] Hazel Pearson,  Newspaper Clipping entitled “Women’s Page.  Attractive Haughey Girls Tell of Days When Life Was Primitive But Delightful In Craig” 1952, newspaper unknown.   Courtesy of Frank Hess

15] Benton Barracks, Missouri history web page
http://www.missouricivilwarmuseum.org/benton.htm

16] Utah State Archives web site research center.  Corporate documents for “Standard Mining and Milling Company”    http://archives.utah.gov/referenc/!referen.htm

17] Piute Free Lance Newpaper.  Transcribed courtesy of Ardis Parshall at
PiuteCountyQuery@aol.com

18] Claudia Linares, CPE Working Paper Series, The Civil War Pension Law,
Working paper 2001-6
www.cpe.uchicago.edu/publication/publication.html   Center For Population Economics, Chicago, IL, 2001


Acknowledgements 

I first became aware of the existence of Francis Marion Haughey's letters to Warren Crandall in March of 2004.  While researching Francis Marion’s Civil War experience, I came across Chester Hearn’s new book, Ellet’s Brigade, The Strangest Outfit of All, about the Mississippi Marine Brigade.  Reading the book, I found a reference in the bibliography to letters in the archives of the Missouri Historical Society written by Francis Marion Haughey.  I would like to thank Dennis Northcott at the Missouri Historical Society for his helpfulness and promptness in sending me copies of the letters. 

I would also like to thank a number of people for helping me compile background information.  Ardis Parshall in Provo, Utah, provided newspaper references for Marysvale history.  My wife Deborah and brother Daniel assisted in editing my drafts.  Finally, I would like to thank cousin Frank Hess, whose grandfather was F.M. Haughey, for his hard work compiling newspaper articles, Bible records, obituaries and other materials which, together with extensive research notes by my father and my brother Daniel, were of great help and inspiration.

Steve Haughey
Great-Great-Grandson of Francis Marion Haughey
steve@shaughey.com


Other Links 

Missouri Archive where FM Haughey letters are found

Museum of Northwest Colorado in Craig Colorado.  Located near the original Haughey Homestead

Mississippi Marine Brigade links.

Mississippi Marine Brigade info

Utah Mining and Marysvale

Last letter of Francis Marion Haughey to his family in Colorado
written 8 days before his death from complications of frostbite.
[Envelope was postmarked Marysvale with Two cent postage]
After ….. days, return to
F.M. Haughey
Marysvale, Utah

Mrs I. A. Haughey
Craig
Routt Co.
Colo

 

Marysvale Piute Co Utah
                                                                          
Feb 6th 1910
To Dear wife and children
I just came off of the mountain last night and will Not return for Some time this has been the Coldest winter so far that has ever Been known in this part of the country Steady Cold some Nights as low as 17 to 21 degrees Below Zero I gave my feet A Bad Chilblain while comeing off of mountain I received A registerd proposition for A three year Bond and Leese which I sent A telegram this morning of Acception to it Los Angeles California in care of P.M. Woodruff to T. A. Woodruff So they might go ahead and draw up the papers Now iff I could get rid of the other group I migh get A lay off

          F. M. Haughey



Death of F.M. Haughey

Francis Marion returned to Marysvale sometime after his last letter to Crandall.  He continued to work on his mining claims and was trying to sell or lease them.  His last letter to his family in Colorado is transcribed in the next section.

On February 5, 1910, Francis Marion came down from the mountains to Marysvale to send a telegram regarding a business deal on some of his mines.  The weather was very cold and during the 8-mile walk his feet were badly frostbitten.  He stayed at a hotel in Marysvale to recover, but he died February 14, 1910, at the age of 75.  His son Robert came from California to bring the body from Marysvale back to Craig, Colorado, where he was buried in Fairfield Cemetery.  The Standard Mining and Milling Company closed in 1910 after his death.  Francis Marion and Isabella were married over 52 years.  After his death, Isabella applied for and received a pension as a widow.  She died in 1912 at the age of 71.

 

Crandall's Book

Warren Crandall published his History of the Ram Fleet and the Mississippi Marine Brigade in 1907. It sold for $2.50.  The buyers were mostly veterans of the Ram Fleet and MMB.  The book includes a photo gallery of over 230 veterans, but unfortunately does not include F.M. Haughey.  I wonder if Francis Marion received his 3 copies, and if so, what has become of them. The copy I purchased had belonged to another MMB veteran, Ed N. Lincoln, of Belvidere, Illinois.  Crandall dedicated his book as follows:

“To the Honor of the Living, and Memory of the Dead, who during three and a half years of Heroic Warfare, afloat and ashore, earned the Gratitude of their Country, in helping to preserve it, an unbroken Heritage of Liberty, for Coming Generations.”

Francis Marion also expressed a wish that future generations remember him and his service to the country.  Following the Battle of Shiloh, he had kept a star from the bullet-riddled flag of the 44th Indiana Volunteers.  He was obviously very proud of the star and the flag for which he had fought.  In closing the first letter to Crandall, he wrote the following:

. . . Most of the men of the Late War will soon pass in their final muster roll . . . but our Nation’s Banner will never be trod under foot as long as there is a son of a veteran left to protect it . . . long may it wave when we are dead over our graves . . . 

        F. M. Haughey  late sergeant Co C Cav M.M.B

Eureka Humbolt California

                                                                                     
Feb 16th 1907
Comerad W. D Crandall you will Excuse Mee for Not Sending My Picture Sooner I was taken Bad with the lagrip And came over to the Coast to recruit up And Am Not in verry good Health yet But you will find my Picture Either in the Express or mail which ever I can get off in the soonest and will send you a Money order in this for $7.50 And it may be I can help you sell quite A Number of your historys iff the People seems to take to that kind of litreture I would have taken a dozen Myself But At the present it has cost Mee quite a lot to come over here And when Ever I think that I am Able to start up work will Return to Utah at Marysvale I just received your last postal card of yours Mailed Jan 17th which followed Mee out here and took ten days to come from Marysval here the Mail is verry slow on the coast iff it dont change hands in a fiew days I will always think it had orto Please let Mee know as soon As your historys are complete
                                                                Francis M. Haughey

[ note, perhaps in Crandall’s handwriting]
#118
Ackd 2/27
Send  [something un-readable]
Query  [something un-readable]

page


 

Visit to Eureka, California, and son Robert

The seventh and last of the letters to Crandall was written from Eureka, California, in 1907.  Francis Marion is now 72 years old and is recovering from “lagrip,” which is a 19th century term for the flu.   He does not say where he is living, but it seems certain that he is with his oldest son Robert and family in Eureka. 

Francis Marion had a close relationship with his eldest son.  In the late 1870’s it was Robert who came out to Colorado from Iowa with his father to try mining at Leadville and helped build the homestead in Routt County. 

Robert lived in Leadville for 18 years and worked in the grocery business. Sometime in the early 1900’s Robert relocated his family to Eureka, California, and started in the lumber business.  He was the proprietor of a shingle mill for many years.   Francis Marion kept in touch with his son while mining in Utah.  The Utah paper “Piute Free Lance” reported on 14 August 1903: 

“FM Haughey was down from [the mines] Wednesday.  While in town Mr. Haughey received word from one of his sons in California that he had suffered the loss of between $30,000 and $40,000 in the burning of his shingle mills.

Francis Marion’s son Grant also came to Eureka briefly to try the lumber business with his older brother Robert but came back to Colorado after a few months to homestead near Craig. The 1930 census shows Robert and family still living in Eureka.  Robert lived to be 86 and passed away in 1946 in California.

In the seventh letter, it is evident that Crandall had asked Francis Marion for a photo to include in the upcoming publication of his history.   Crandall had originally intended to publish biographical information about the veterans, but finding that he had so little material for this, he decided to include just a gallery of photos of the members of the Ram Fleet and MMB.

Mee whether to purchase or Not of course there are some so called Experts that are all ok I have have saw men go to take samples from A Mine and Never took any of the regular Mineral in the vein But his samples were taking from the country Rocks there are to great a percent of would Be Experts that could Expert A Saloon or gambling house Better than A Mine as there is where they have gained so much of their knowledge was when they were siting Near some pool table with their heels up on the side of the table on a level with what brain they had Excuse Mee Comerad for Making those remarks But they are Matter of facts there is A sham for some one to get a great Bargain out of Mee By Coming to mee themselves and see what they are getting

              F.M. Haughey

Letter

[rubber stamp at top]
                         Standard Mining & Milling Co.
                        
Marysvale Utah


                                                                                        May 20th, 1906

W.D. Crandall
4631 Evans Avenue
St Louise Mo

        Dear Comerad
I
just Received your letter of May the third Allways glad to hear from the comerads the Most of us are getting well up in years and cannot expect to stop but a fiew years at the best    Concerning the Mineing Rotine that is generaly is went through I have seen plenty of it during My life iff there was less so called Mining Experts the country and Capitalist and owners of Mining property would Be Better off as there are plenty of them that Never struck A pick in the ground much less hit A drill iff I wanted to make any large Deal I dont want several men to dictate to

 

 

page


Mining Experts and Appraisers

The sixth letter to Crandall was written just a couple of months after the last one.  In his previous letter, Francis Marion “talked up” the great value of his mining claims and appealed to Crandall to help him find “men of means” to invest in his mines.  Crandall had sent him a reply, which quickly generated this counter reply.  The letter reveals a bit of frustration.  Probably Crandall did not offer any help with finding investors for the mines.  In my imagination, Crandall’s reply to the last letter might have gone something like this . . .

Dear Comrade Haughey, 

Thank you for your interesting information on your claims.  At this time I do not know of any investors for your enterprise but I will keep it in mind.  Do you have any reports or appraisals of your claims from geologists or mining experts?  These could be valuable in generating interest in your property . . .

                         W.D. Crandall"

Whatever Crandall wrote, he soon found out what F.M. Haughey thought about “mining experts!"  I’m sure in those wild boom-time mining days there were a lot of shady dealings and shifty characters trying to make a fast buck as so called mining experts!

Here is the Google maps link to the general area of Francis Marion's mining claim.   Although not that many miles from Marysvale, I am sure the trip down from 10,000 feet to the town was difficult.
Map

[Note on back side of map]
Plat of the group of Claims in which I have Mentioned in my letter which are called the 16 To one Numberd from one to Nine

[ Page 4 of F.M. Haughey’s 5th letter is a full page map of his claims including lines showing locations of veins with number designations.  It also includes various geographic locations including “Iron peak,” “Horse Heaven peak,” “falls of 2 mile creek,” “Bergam Peak,”  “3 mile falls,” and a trail.    Altitude 10,000 feet  ]

page

PS
I
n case of sale for cash your commission will Be ten percent iff we organize A good Company and Stock the same you will have to take your Commission in Stock on the Same Company
 
                     F. M. Haughey

The Largest gold vein of quarts is in A telareum Nature and verry large running South of west and North of East and various other veins running South East and North west towards the Camouse Ana Laura Mine at Kimberly which theyre fused  five million for I saw all of the same Before they had struck their ore So I had orto to know what I am doing

Letter

Now Comerad in reference to organizing a company on this group and [struck out] of property iff you can assist Mee in getting good men of Means to take hold with Mee as I have great faith in it Making A great Mine iff Capitol might want to purchase that group for cash I would sell it for $30,000 But would Rather have it worked than sell it as there are Numerous Mineral veins crossing the property and this is in the heart of a Mineral region which will when properly worked produce Millions in gold and silver Now Comerad iff you are Aquainted with Men of Capitol that might want to invest let Mee know soon as there will Be lots of that kind of people here as soon as the snow is out of the mountains so let mee hear from you soon as posible Before others come as first come first served
                                              F. M. Haughey

Letter

Marysvale
Piute County
Utah
March 13th 1906

Comerads Received yours of Feb 28 and were glad to hear from you all I will take three of those Historys I would be glad to meet all of you once more But my presence is Needed here to Atend to Matters here I am engaged in Mining have Been up in the mountains all winter I have the making of some fine property for a company I have charge of two groups of claims one of eleven claims and one of Nine claims I was thinking of organizing a stock company on the group of Nine and have the property pattented and worked as fast as Means and men could do it this property predominates in gold

Letter

Mining in Utah and the Search for Investors

The fifth letter from F.M. Haughey to Warren Crandall was written in 1906, three years after the last one.  Francis Marion is still in Marysvale, which continues to grow as a mining district.  A spur line of the Denver and Rio Grand railroad reached Marysvale in 1900, bringing more people and activity to the area.  Marysvale is a town with a colorful history.  Butch Cassidy was born just a few miles away in Beaver in 1866, and was active in the area for many years until around 1901, when he left for South America.  He is said to have stayed in Marysvale hotels a number of times during the period F.M. Haughey was prospecting.  Perhaps Francis Marion saw Butch on one of his visits?

Francis Marion started acquiring mining claims in Utah around 1892.  In about 1897 he formed the Standard Mining and Milling Company, which seems to have encompassed just some of his 20 claims.  He sold stock in his company to raise money to work these claims.  Over the next 13 years, he operated his company and developed the mines.   Although there does not seem to be any evidence that he produced much ore or made much money, he must have worked very hard in pursuit of his dream.  Mining laws required that the claim be worked and improved continually in order to keep the claim.   In this fifth letter to Crandall, Francis Marion expresses interest in finding investors to start a second company with his remaining claims.  

The mines were located in the mountains about 5 miles southeast of Marysvale at an altitude of 10,000 feet.   It was an 8-mile walk or ride into town.  Francis Marion, in his sixties and seventies while he prospected in Marysvale, often lived up in the mountains near his claims.  He traveled into town when needed.

The local papers in Marysvale reported the following:

   26 February 1898: “ F.M. Haughey was down from the Standard Tuesday. He feels greatly encouraged over what is shown up by recent developments. (PP)

   26 September 1902:
  F.M. Haughey was down from Horse Heaven last Monday, and reports work in the Snow Bird No. 2 tunnel as progressing nicely.(PFL)

   25 September 1903:  "
F.M. Haughey of the 1 to 1 and Standard properties returned Sunday evening from a trip to Salt Lake."(PFL) 

   1 July 1904:  "F.M. Haughey was down from the hills for a few days this week."(PFL) 

At the beginning of this letter, Francis Marion also mentions that he wants three of the “Historys,” meaning the soon-to-be-published book by Crandall.  The veterans were asked to subscribe before publication.

Flyer to recruit men in hospitals for the Mississippi Marine brigade

The men from hospitals who joined the MMB traveled to “Benton Barracks” to organize. Benton Barracks was a large military camp outside St. Louis. It had many uses during the Civil War, including training camp, hospital, camp for POW's, and refuge for hundreds of runaway slaves.  New regiments were organized and mustered into service at Benton Barracks.  In late 1862 and early 1863 the MMB also used this facility, and this is where F.M. Haughey began his service.

Flyer

I will enclose Money order to you for one Dollar

    F.M. Haughey Sargent
                Co C Cavalry
                of  M. M. Brigade


[written on the back side of the letter, perhaps in Crandall’s handwriting]

#118   [Crandall appears to have written #118 on all FMH letters, perhaps a number assigned to keep track of the hundreds of veterans]
    Ack’d 6/23/03
    & fully ansd &
    Sent him pamphlet
 [I think regarding Crandall’s upcoming book. Pub 1907]
    Roll & H 20 & 21   
[I don’t know what this notation meant to Crandall]

page

of our former service by one Mustering officer and Mustered in immediately in to the M. M. Brigade by another officer Now I am getting Near my 69 birth day and iff this government is going to treat all cases of the same kind Alike it is time they were doing it as we cannot expect to survive many More years I made Application for A pension under George E Lemons time of pension agent Please let Me hear from you on this subject to see whether My ideas are correct on the General order

page

correct Please let mee know as the department on the pension Business tries to make it appear that all convalesent that reenlisted is Not entitled to a pension This is a matter that I would like for the pension department to fully understand I was one of the convalescent at No 8 hospital New Albany Ind when the order came to the hospital and there was Near 70 of us reported to General A W Eliott and Received our transportation at once to Benton Barrack Mo and was Mustered out

page

To recruit his Brigade from the Secretary of war what was the Number of it to the best of my recollection it was No 89 I may be rong and Read something like this you are hereby authorized to recruit A command to be known as the Mississippi Marine Brigade and to be composed of one thousand Mounted Infantry and one hundred and fifty Artilery and the same was to be recruited from convalescent soldiers and citizens Now iff you know whether this is

page

Mo. 100   [At top, in a different hand (Crandall?) Perhaps a reference to the one dollar]

Marysval Piute County
Utah June 17th 1903

To Comerad W.D. Crandal Historian of the M.M.B it has Been A long time since I have seen or heard from any of the old comerads I am Not drawing any pension as yet I was cripled up for a Number of years After I was Musterd out of the service I was on Board the US Woodford when she was scuddled on the Red river and we had to leave her there Now there is one question I want to ask you and that is this when Gener A W Eliott Received A general order

page


Convalescents Recruited for the MMB

The fourth letter, from 1903, was written 15 years after the previous one.  F.M. Haughey is now in the mining town of Marysvale, Utah, and is 68 years old.    In 1866, Congress had ruled that mineral deposits in the public domain were free and open to exploration and occupation.  In the 1880's, southeastern Utah became the site of another gold and silver rush.  Francis Marion, who had tried mining in Colorado before homesteading there, must have been attracted by this new mining boom.  Around 1892, once again, he left his family behind and traveled to Marysvale to stake his claims. 

 

In the fourth letter, he talks again about his troubles obtaining a pension.  He asks about specifics of the terms of enlistment, and recalls how he was in a New Albany, Indiana, hospital when he was recruited.

 

The following is from Crandall's 1907 book about the MMB (p. 253):

“Recruiting for the new Brigade was, however, soon found to be slow and difficult.  The large bounties paid, and the drafts made in various states to enable them to make up their quota of troops, operated strongly against the securing of men for the new command, which, belonging to no particular state, could offer no bounty to recruits, as inducement to enter its service.   Again, men proposing to enlist naturally preferred to enter companies and regiments raised in their immediate locality.  To overcome these difficulties , and accelerate the work of recruiting, General Ellet wrote to Washington proposing the enlistment of convalescent men from the hospitals.”

Crandall also quotes this letter, written December 13, 1862, from Alfred Ellet  to Major General H. W. Halleck (p. 254)

“ . . . I would further suggest that these men be obtained from the convalescents in hospitals.  Many men who are utterly unfitted for ordinary service in the field would make efficient soldiers for this service which is so much lighter and less fatiguing.”

Halleck replied in agreement with this plan on Dec. 21, 1862, and there followed

Special order No 89 - Headquarters Department of Missouri

Pursuant to order from the Secretary of War, Brigadier General Ellet is authorized to enlist convalescents from any hospital.  Captain Burrill, U.S. Mustering Officer, upon orders from General Ellet, will muster out any such soldiers or recruits as report to him.

           By command of Major General Curtis

In December 1862 and January 1863, recruiters for the MMB visited hospitals in St. Louis, Louisville, Nashville, Cincinnati and New Albany.  Crandall's book also includes the following text from a handbill used by the recruiter at hospitals.  The MMB recruiters said:

At the white house.  Comerads please give three cheers for Harison to our Next President. Also three cheers for the old comerads and defender of our union three Rousing Smiles to the opponent to Harison Hoping that he may be Left Behind on the race we had Enough vetoes out of him Away with Such Reform of goverment for mee is my prayer

                       Your in FCL  [?]
               F M Haughey
  PM
                       Yampa Routt Co
                                    Colo
Formily A member of Co C
Cav M M Brigade
PS
        Comrads please let mee
        Hear from you all By
        Letters
  you can do so
        and I will Answer the same

 Comerad Crandall you can Read this to our old comerads of our brigade at your reunion if you please there may Be some that may want to hear from mee

page
Comerad Crandall I have just received your communication Also Comerad Newell which I have just Answered A fiew moments ago Comerad I desire that you place My Name upon your Roll As A member of the old M. M Brigade I will enclose one dollar in this and whatever Necessary expences there is Attached to the member ship please enform mee and I will remit the same As you or any offices of the order that you may direct so to do A I can not meet with the old comerads on the 12 of September which I am sorry to But this much comerads I must say my well wishes is with you all as comerads as Defenders of our American flag Now comerads let us rally once around the old Ballot Box and Show to our old comerade Harison that the cartridge that we shoot at the election is not all Blanks but mean Busines as defenders of the union and once more, After the Battle is fought, that we may Be Able to vive a say in loud hip hip huray for our old comerad and Commander In Chief at the
page


3rd Letter to Warren Crandall

At top, written "Yampa Colo  8-17  1888"

Message to MMB Reunion and Election of 1888

F.M. Haughey's third letter to Warren Crandall was written in August of 1888, just before a September reunion of the MMB and a few months before the Presidential election.

F.M. Haughey is a strong supporter of the candidate Benjamin Harrison, and he obviously disliked the incumbent President Grover Cleveland.  Cleveland was the first Democrat elected after the Civil War.  He was not popular with the GAR veterans because of his reform policies, which included opposing special favors to any economic group.  He vetoed many private pension bills to Civil War veterans, including bills that would have provided pensions for disabilities not caused by military service.

Future President Harrison, elected in November 1888, led the 70th Indiana Regiment in the Civil War and was eventually promoted to Brigadier General.   In the 1880’s, Harrison served in the US Senate and championed Indians, homesteaders, and Civil War veterans.  He was also active in Civil War reunions.  In the election of 1888, he received 100,000 fewer popular votes than Cleveland, but carried the Electoral College 233 to 168.  During his presidency he championed pensions for GAR veterans.

F.M. Haughey asked Crandall several times for help documenting his Civil War service-related injury.  Since most of the MMB records were destroyed, he needed to find witnesses to testify that his disability was a result of his service in order to receive a pension.

In 1890, during Harrison’s term, there was a law passed to institute a pension for disability even if it was unrelated to war.  I think F.M. Haughey may still not have received a pension before his death in 1910.  There appears to be no record of his ever receiving one.

deal yet at times and am Greatly reduced there By my usual weight 225 lbs even high as 245 when in fight at Donalson now only 165 so can see what a great change has taken place I came into this mountain country to try and regain my health and have benefited some thereby if you knew the where abouts of Capt O. F. Brown or Lieut Barton or Lieut Wicoff of Co C cav M. M. B. or any one else that you may know of that might know any thing of my circumstances or the whereabout of Asst. Surgeon Eldridge

F. M. Haughey late of Co C cav

Letter
Now if you can call to memory any of the case or can make a statement of mee Being Sent on Board the U.S. Woodford from the flag ship Autocrat I was on Board the Woodford when She sank on the falls of Red River and from the time that I was ordered By the general to report on Hospital Bot U.S. Woodford to Brigade Surgeon for treatment Never was able for duty from that time and done None while in the Service only Something of A light duty and was cripled for many years after and troubled a great
Letter
ordered By General Ellett in person to report myself to the Brigade Surgeon on Board of the U.S. Woodford for medical Treatment for an injury that I had received in A line of duty of my right leg which was never healed until after I came into Colorado when I was discharged if you recollect was when the command was consolidated at Vicksburg I was renderd Supernumerary By the Consolidation and the captain did Not make any mention or remarks in my discharge concerning my injurys therefore it has prevented mee so far from receiving my just dues for the same
Letter

Comerad W D Crandall

I wold like a list of all of the old comerads that you have and their Address as there is Some of them if Living might Be of A considerable service to mee in obtaining my Just dues as A Soldier of the M. M. B. perhaps you may reecollect mee and my circumstances in Connection with the commissary I acted commissary for the Brigade while At Benton Barracks while they were recruiting for the Brigade and afterward commissary Sargent on Board of your Boat until
Letter


2nd Letter to Warren Crandall

At top, stamped in a horse shoe shaped rubber stamp "Yampa Colorado Nov 27 1887"

 

Trouble with Pensions and Reminiscences of the MMB

In his new book on the MMB, Chester Hearn references F.M. Haughey’s letters regarding his trouble obtaining a pension.  As the historian and keeper of the remaining records, Warren Crandall was in a position to help veterans prove their claims to the pension office.  F.M. Haughey filed a pension claim in 1881, but it was apparently rejected. The pension system in the 1880’s provided for payment only if you could prove both service and disability caused by injury in the line of duty.   I do not know if Francis Marion's leg injury occurred during his service in the MMB or earlier in the 44th.  Likely his claim was rejected either because there were no documents showing he had been injured in the service, or because his injury was not considered a sufficient disability to qualify for the pension. 

The MMB’s fleet of converted steamboats included one hospital ship, the US Woodford.  Francis Marion was serving on this boat when, during the MMB’s “Red River Expedition” of March 1864, the ship was damaged as it tried to pass the falls at Alexandria, Louisiana, and it sank. 

Francis Marion Haughey was a large man.  In his enlistment papers his height is given as 6’ 2”.  In this second letter, when he writes about his weight “at Donalson,” I believe he is referring to the Battle of Fort Donelson in February 1862 in which the 44th Indiana participated.   This battle, which was a precursor to the Battle of Shiloh, was the Union’s first major victory of the war and gained fame and support for U.S. Grant as a military leader.

right things will soon make A great change for the most of the men of the Late War will soon pass in their final Muster roll and only known of as the past but our Nation Banner will Never be trod under foot as long as there is A son of veteran Left to protect it Long may it wave when we are dead wave over our graves I have in my possession A star of the old flag of the 44 Ind volunteers which was riddled with bullets at the Battle of Shilo and hung only by one small thread I took it and sent it home to my wife in a letter and had her take care of it and money would Not purchase it as poor as I am

yours Fraternally

            F. M. Haughey  late sergent Co C Cav
                                                                M.M.B

 

letter 1

 

comerad crandall you may think strange when I tell you that the Nearest post of the gov is one hundred and ten miles and that is the nearest rail road station also there is more rebel soldiers in this country than there is of the union soldiers Some of old marmadukes men live in this part that is the old reb that we usto have so much trouble with on the Mississippi they do not have much to say on the past  they usto though whenever they heard that the president had vetoed some pension Bill some of them are verry bitter pills yet and others seem to be all right and trying to do what is

letter 1

 

ever receveing any thing from the government yet or I Never could hear from any of my company officers  I went out to Colorado to see what I could do there and regain my health this is A verry healthy climate I would be verry glad to Attend your reunion and meet all of my old comerads one more but I have A large family of six Boys and 4 girls and am doing all I am Able in my old days to make my last days the most pleasant of my life it does mee good to meet an old comerad or have A correspondence with them I have taken the National tribune for several years and have watched the Names of those old comerads that were Numbered among these that are No more to be enrolled on this side of eternity

 

letter 1

6-28-1887

Dear Sir and comerad I receved your card today and must say was hapily surprised to get one from you Not having seen or heard of you since I was mustered out at Vicksburg when the command was consolidated I was rendered supernumerary By consolidation you well recollect mee by joging your memory I was stationed on the flag ship for a long time as commissary sargent I belonged to Co C Cav  O.F. Brown captain commanding  Barton and Wicoff[?] was the Lieut  my rank in the company was sargent I was cripled at the time of mustering out at Vicksburg and captain failed to make any menthion of the fact at that time which has debared mee so far from

letter 1

The following is a transcription of Francis Marion Haughey’s first letter to Warren Crandall.  In the transcription I have tried to be faithful to his spelling, capitalization and punctuation.  Standardization of spelling was not widespread  in the 19th century.   He does not use periods, so sentences tend to run together. 


1st Letter to Warren Crandall

At top, stamped YAMPA Routt County COLO

Origin of the Letters

This set of 7 letters was written by Francis Marion Haughey between 1887 and 1907 to Warren Crandall, a fellow veteran of the Civil War.  The letters provide a glimpse into F.M. Haughey’s Civil War service and parts of his life in the years that followed.  He was not a career soldier or a decorated war hero, but the war was probably the defining event of his long life.  As these letters show, Francis Marion exhibited a bit of the wanderlust typical of the American experience in the 19th century.  Farmer in the Midwest, soldier for the Union, homesteader in Colorado, prospector in Utah, energetic to say the least, Francis Marion Haughey is a good example of the men who rushed to volunteer in the first months of the war. 

Warren D. Crandall was a former officer and the official historian for the veterans' Society of Survivors for the Union 1st Mississippi Marine Brigade.   The letters that F.M. Haughey wrote to him have been preserved as part of a collection entitled "Warren D. Crandall Papers” at the Missouri Historical Society in St.Louis.   The letters were also cited as reference material in the bibliography of the new book Ellet’s Brigade, The Strangest Outfit of All, by Chester G. Hearn.  This history of the Ram Fleet and the 1st Mississippi Marine Brigade was published in 2000.

 

Start of the Civil War and the 44th Indiana

Francis Marion Haughey was born in Ashland County, Ohio, on January 28, 1835.  He was the tenth of 14 children of Robert and Hannah Wyckoff Haughey, who named their son Francis Marion in honor of the famous Revolutionary War hero.  In 1861, at the outbreak of the Civil War, F.M. Haughey and his wife Isabella were living on a farm in Indiana.  They had two children: 3-year-old Hannah Jane, and Robert Lincoln, born in January of that year on his father's birthday.   Within 5 months of President Lincoln’s first call for volunteers, Francis Marion enrolled for service with the Indiana Volunteers.  In November, he was mustered into the newly organized 44th Indiana Infantry as a private for his first term of service in the Civil War.  At his enlistment, he stated his age as 27 years. His height was 6’ 2”; he had light complexion, blue eyes and dark hair.

He served with the 44th for a little over one year.  At the start of his service he was a private in the infantry, and in March of 1862 he became an orderly for a Colonel in the regiment.   In his letters he makes references to two of the engagements of the 44th Indiana: battles in Tennessee at Fort Donelson in February 1862, and at Shiloh in April 1862.  

During his service in the 44th he became ill with typhoid.  He was in hospital at least twice and was even sent home for a period of time in June of 1862. He returned to duty but was taken sick again in November 1862 and transferred to a hospital in New Albany, Indiana.  His illness was apparently not completely debilitating because he managed to serve as a cook while in hospital.  It was during this time at New Albany that he was approached by recruiters for the 1st Mississippi Marine Brigade.  Apparently Francis Marion liked what the recruiters said, for on January 15, 1863, he mustered out of the 44th and into the Marine Brigade, and the second chapter of his Civil War service began.

 

The Mississippi Marine Brigade

The 1st Mississippi Marine Brigade (MMB) and the Mississippi Ram Fleet were special Federal Units raised directly by the War Department and were not a part of any state.  Their unique organization, chain of command, and origin made them some of the strangest military units of the Civil War.  

The Ram Fleet was the brainchild of the eminent 19th century engineer Charles Ellet, Jr.   Before the war Ellet had gained fame for his construction of bridges, including the first suspension bridge in America, over the Schuykill River in Philadelphia in 1842, and the longest suspension bridge in the world, over the Ohio River at Wheeling, in 1849. 

After the start of the war, Charles Ellet wanted to do something to help the war effort.   He lobbied in Washington to be allowed to use his engineering talents to build a fleet of steam riverboats to be used as rams to sink Confederate ships on the western rivers.  In March of 1862, when the Confederate ironclad ram CSS Virginia (Merrimack) and the USS Monitor had their famous battle at Hampton Roads, Virginia, the War Department in Washington became worried that the South would build similar ironclad boats for the Mississippi River.  Ellet was finally granted permission to start buying commercial Mississippi steamboats and converting them into fast “rams”. 

In late 1862, Ellet decided that he needed to add a group of cavalry and infantry soldiers to serve on his boats to attack Rebel units along the riverbanks.  The Mississippi Marine Brigade was formed to fill this role.   Horses were transported on steamboats with the troops and could land at points along the river where they encountered Confederate troops or guerilla bands.   Typical actions of the MMB included protection of Union riverboats and actions against smaller Rebel bands.   They also served to protect Southern plantation owners who had sworn loyalty to the Union and agreed to sell cotton to the North.

In his first letter, Francis Marion recalls troubles the MMB had with Confederate General John Marmaduke, who had set up an artillery battery on the heights above the Mississippi river to destroy Union shipping.  This was a particularly hard-fought battle and one of the few times the MMB fought against experienced, regular army Confederate units.

The MMB and the Ram Fleet were controversial.  At the time they were organized, they reported directly to the Secretary of War and as such, did not take orders from the Navy or the Army.  This caused continual friction between the Ram Fleet and the Union Army and Navy units fighting on the Mississippi River.  During their service on the Mississippi, the command changed hands frequently, first to the Navy, and later to the Army under General Grant.  Other military leaders, who resented not having control over the MMB, often criticized their actions.

During the war, the Ram Fleet and MMB were responsible for the destruction or capture of numerous Confederate steamboats and at least one ironclad.  Their land action along the river included many engagements and resulted in the capture of a considerable amount of Confederate supplies and valuable cotton. 

Francis Marion Haughey’s service record shows that he was promoted to Commissary Sergeant within days of his enlistment.  He served in that position for about 6 months until he was again taken ill.  He may have had a reoccurrence of typhoid, or perhaps he suffered a leg injury.  He was once again put on furlough for 4 months, from July to October of 1863.  Upon his return in November he was stationed on the hospital ship US Woodford.  He was sometimes listed as a patient on the boat and sometimes simply as present in the company.  In August of 1864, the War Department chose to disband the MMB and consolidate parts of the unit with other commands.  Francis Marion was mustered out of the service August 24, 1864, at Vicksburg, Mississippi.

At the end of the war, someone in the war office at Vicksburg discarded the records of the unit as “worthless.”   This made life difficult for the veterans when it came time to apply for pensions.   It also meant that, unless other records could be found, much of the unit’s history would not be recorded in the official government history of the war.

 

Post War

After the war, Francis Marion Haughey returned to farming in DeKalb County, Indiana.  By 1868, the family had grown to include 5 children, with the birth of Francis Marion Grant ("Grant M.") in June.  Later that same year the family moved to Stewart, Iowa.  In March,1879, Isabella gave birth to the couple's tenth and last child, Blanche Maud.  About that same time, Francis Marion and his 18-year-old son Robert left the family in Iowa and traveled to Colorado.  There they tried their hand at silver mining in Leadville, and in Kokomo, in Summit County.  In 1884, while working in Leadville, Francis Marion decided to explore further west, and he traveled to Moffat County, in northwestern Colorado, near present-day Craig (now in Routt County). He liked the country and decided to give up mining and to homestead.  Veterans had homesteading rights allowing them to acquire land. 

Francis Marion and son Grant built a log cabin of hand-hewn cottonwood logs. The house was 16 feet square and had a basement under the kitchen.  A fireplace in the basement had a chimney that connected with the kitchen on the ground floor.

By 1886 they were ready for the rest of the family to come to Colorado.  Isabella and the children came by train to the nearest station in Rawlins, Wyoming.  They brought a limited amount of furniture and Isabella carried a dozen baby chickens in a box for their new home.    Francis Marion met them and brought the family overland by wagon and “Indian pony train.” The journey of 120 miles took three days to reach the homestead.  Francis Marion hunted antelope to provide fresh meat for the family.

Upon arrival, the family settled into life on their homestead.  Deer and elk skins covered the dirt floor of the new cabin.   The women canned food, made clothing, and learned to ride horsed and hunt deer.  The men raised cattle and harvested lumber on the homestead.

A year after moving the family, Francis Marion wrote his first letter to Warren Crandall.

 

Crandall’s Work to Restore the Lost History of the MMB

Twenty years after the war ended, Warren Crandall, the former Assistant Adjutant General for the MMB, was actively involved in reconstructing the lost records.  He had become the Brigade’s historian and collected hundreds of letters, records, ships’ log books, and other material to document the history of the unit.  Using this material, he would eventually publish a history of the unit in 1907.  Over the years, Crandall corresponded with the “Comrades” of the MMB, sending out newsletters and inviting members to reunions.   F.M. Haughey’s responses to these letters are among Crandall's papers that have been saved in the archives of the Missouri Historical Society.

 

 

Contents Quick Links

F.M. Haughey
W. D. Crandall
Francis Marion
    Haughey
Warren D. Crandall

Ram Boat
Mining